Protect Maine Questions Why the State Doesn't Want to Look Under the Salmon Farms

A recent Sentient Media article took a look at testing under Cooke Aquaculture’s net pens. Heather Govern (CLF), Crystal Canney (PMFHF), and Dwayne Shaw (DSF) were quoted:

“Govern and Canney also argue that the state lacks sufficient independent sampling and inspections beneath the net pens, while Shaw points to gaps in monitoring escaped farmed salmon.”

Read the entire story here: bit.ly/4hHXECP

This is an important point about independent testing beneath the salmon pens. In July, Protect Maine’s Executive Director and its President Rock Alley of Jonesport approached the Department of Marine Resources (DMR) Commissioner at a scallop hearing to ask a simple question – Why is DMR allowing Cooke with its history of  violations around the world  to do testing and monitoring underneath its own net pens and report the findings?  The unfortunate truth is the DMR Commissioner didn’t have an answer.  Protect Maine feels it’s unacceptable when the department is using a grant funded robot under the water to site lease already and is failing to use it underneath the net pens which would increase transparency and government oversight.

Read DMR’s press release on its grant funded machine: https://www1.maine.gov/dmr/news/tue-08192025-1200-grant-supports-continued-efficiency-improvements-maine-dmr-aquaculture

Mainers Fight to Protect Wild Salmon From Fish Farms

For more than three decades, Dwayne Shaw has fought to keep wild Atlantic salmon from disappearing in Maine. As the executive director of the Downeast Salmon Federation, he helps operate hatcheries and restore rivers and watersheds where the last remaining wild Atlantic salmon in the United States exist. The Atlantic salmon fisheries closed in the 1940s after dams, pollution and overfishing drove the population into decline. “We have secured them, to an extent. However, they remain at critically low levels,” Shaw tells Sentient.

Now, Shaw worries that the recovery of Maine’s endangered wild salmon could be jeopardized by other salmon: those raised in open-net cages along the coast.

New Lawsuit Against Salmon Greenwashing

Sound familiar? This lawsuit filed on behalf of Farm Stand speaks to alleged misleading representations of “sustainably farmed” salmon.  

The lawsuit looks at the Chilean waters of Patagonia where net pen salmon have been driven by large corporations. 

Among the issues in the suit,

o   Parasites

o   Impact on the marine environment

o   Depleting forage fish to make food to grow the farmed salmon

o   Crowded industrial net pens

o   Excess nutrients

These are some of the similarities cited in Conservation Law Foundation’s suit against Cooke Aquaculture.


Friendship Lobster Boat Races

Protect Maine at the Union Fair

Maine should better understand the risks of salmon farming

The Maine coast has long sustained thriving ecosystems, natural beauty and generations of fishers and wild harvesters. These same waters now support windjammer sailing, coastal hiking and whale-watching tours. But quietly, Maine state officials are clearing a regulatory path for a potentially damaging industry: industrial fish farming. While other regions are closing salmon farms due to their environmental toll, Maine has become one of the last remaining viable areas in the United States for their expansion.

An alluring pitch for oceanfront fish farming is that it generates reliable jobs by producing sustainable and efficient food without depleting the ocean. Scientists use standard metrics to evaluate these claims, including the “fish-in, fish-out” ratio, which shows how many pounds of wild fish inputs, rendered into fish meal and oil, that it can take to produce a single pound of farmed fish output.

June 2026 Update

If you ever wondered if industrial scale aquaculture was a serious problem, the news in the past few months tells us it is AND more so than ever. In this newsletter we are going to deal with salmon raised in net pens in the ocean. But it’s not just farmed salmon, we are seeing an increasing number of foreign companies that operate leases in Maine waters for exclusive use.

Protect Maine has been working around the state and in Downeast towns to pass ordinances and provide information about the potential dangers of farm raised salmon. Nine communities have passed ordinances that fit within in their communities. Protect Maine - Ordinances

Op-ed: Maine’s working waterfront is not for sale

Written by Crystal Canney. This op-ed originally appeared in The Rising Tide.

Maine’s coastal waters are among the last truly shared public resources left in New England. These scenic waters are the backbone of a working waterfront built over generations by lobstermen, clammers, and independent aquaculturists. 

But Maine’s coastal waters are increasingly being carved up, leased out, monetized, and consolidated into the hands of large, often foreign-owned, vertically integrated corporations. State regulations are not keeping up with these realities. Under state law, lease holders of Maine’s waters can be (and are) foreign corporations. These lease holders are allowed to exclusively control up to 1,000 acres of Maine’s coastal waters, in 100-acre increments, for a term of up to 20 years, with minimal governmental oversight. 

Companies like Cooke Aquaculture—a multinational salmon farming behemoth with a 640-acre footprint in Maine—is the largest example of industrial-scale ocean farming and corporatization. Cooke’s open-net pen systems have sparked environmental and legal scrutiny worldwide, including here in Maine where they are being sued by the Conservation Law Foundation for discharging pollutants into Maine waters in violation of the Clean Water Act. Indeed, Washington State banned net pen salmon farming following a massive fish escape catastrophe at one of Cooke’s West Coast facilities several years ago. 

At the same time, we are now watching in real time a corporate power-grab happening in Maine’s tidal rivers and estuaries. 

On the Damariscotta River, Encore Consumer Capital, a U.S.-based private equity firm, acquired Atlantic Aqua Farms and then flipped it to a multi-billion-dollar Canadian pension fund. Private equity has invested heavily in shellfish production in Maine recent years: in 2025, the fund added Mook Sea Farm to its portfolio. 

Mook Sea Farm, founded in the early days of oyster farming on the Damariscotta, is known for its branded oysters like Pemaquid Point and Wiley Point. But Mook is now an “operating entity” of Atlantic Aqua Farms. In other words, it is a subsidiary that exists on paper to maintain local brand identity but is controlled in nearly all respects by Atlantic Aqua Farms and the pension fund— strategic players in what investors call the “global food basket,” where ocean space becomes a commodity and loyalties are owed only to shareholders. 

So, what happens when public waters transfer hands to private interests? 

The industrialization of aquaculture in Maine is changing the character of Maine’s coastal economy. Growth is the name of the game. Leases that were once measured in small acreage are expanding in size, duration, and intensity. Increasingly, leases are controlled by entities far removed from the resources they extract and the communities they impact. 

For Maine’s remaining independent aquaculturists, this trend creates an uneven playing field. Consolidation puts public waters in the hands of companies with a single motive: profit. And those profits quickly leave Maine. For instance, in 2024, Glenn Cooke, the owner of Cooke Aquaculture, bragged that his companies were worth $4 billion. Yet, Cooke leases Maine’s waters for a mere $100 per acre. 

Maine’s coastal communities are at a crossroads. We need to decide whether Maine’s coastal waters will remain a shared public trust or become a long-term asset class for distant investors. 

We need a recalibration of who benefits from Maine’s “blue economy.” State policies must prevent the commodification of our coastal water and instead prioritize local control by limiting consolidation of lease holdings, strengthening local ownership requirements, and ensuring that decisions of how our waters are allocated and used are made by the communities that bear the costs. It is high time for the State to invest in a sustainable blue economy—one that values our working waterfront heritage, ecological resilience, transparent governance, and long-term community stewardship over short-term financial extraction and reckless growth. 

By keeping aquaculture local, we can embrace economic and environmental strategy that preserves competition, protects working waterfronts, and ensures that Maine’s coastal future is shaped by the communities who depend on it, not by financial institutions whose interests end at the edge of a balance sheet. 

Push to ‘supersize’ aquaculture is not right for Maine | Opinion

President Trump’s calls to “supersize” the American aquaculture industry, outlined in a May 14 Guardian article, are increasingly framed as a path toward seafood independence and domestic food security. But in places like Maine, where industrial salmon farming already operates, the reality is far more complicated.

After a 2017 net-pen collapse in Washington state released hundreds of thousands of farmed salmon into public waters, that state moved to phase out non-native salmon farming.

Maine is now the last place in the United States where Atlantic salmon are raised in open ocean pens, in the same coastal waters where endangered wild Atlantic salmon migrate and persist. As a result, Maine has become a primary foothold for Cooke Aquaculture, a Canadian multinational and one of the world’s largest producers of farmed salmon.

The environmental concerns surrounding industrial salmon farming are not theoretical. In the context of ocean farming, they include nutrient pollution from fish waste and excess feed, the spread of parasites and disease in densely stocked pens and the risk of farmed fish escaping and interacting with wild populations that have evolved over thousands of years.